17 years ago
Thursday, October 16, 2008
Tuesday, October 14, 2008
Response
From Eric V... 2. Is reality TV, such as cops, a documentary in that it does show an on going story with dialogue?
I do not believe that this would be considered a documentary according to Hempe. There is no planned shots, so it is real, but there is also no story, just a combination of events. The storyline does not mix it or tell anything, it is just reoccuring themes and low-level interviews. The most documentary-ish style of the show is the post-arrest interviews. The cops generally tell what happened without being led in by loaded questions, so they're stories are genuine to what they can remember honestly happening.
I do not believe that this would be considered a documentary according to Hempe. There is no planned shots, so it is real, but there is also no story, just a combination of events. The storyline does not mix it or tell anything, it is just reoccuring themes and low-level interviews. The most documentary-ish style of the show is the post-arrest interviews. The cops generally tell what happened without being led in by loaded questions, so they're stories are genuine to what they can remember honestly happening.
Questions
1. Hampe's section titled 'Good Images Don't Just Happen' speaks of the problems of having a good documentary compared to a real depiction of what is actually occuring in reality. How do you feel the craze of reality tv has played into this theme?
2. What do you feel Hampe would say in response to YouTube productions and the endless sources of video we now have at our fingertips?
3. Hampe says that we must 'plan the visual evidence that needs to be record...and recognize when it occurs.' Do you feel it is a paradox to plan to record evidence without recognizing the reality of it until after the shot? Or is the method it must follow to make the documentary as 'real' as possible?
2. What do you feel Hampe would say in response to YouTube productions and the endless sources of video we now have at our fingertips?
3. Hampe says that we must 'plan the visual evidence that needs to be record...and recognize when it occurs.' Do you feel it is a paradox to plan to record evidence without recognizing the reality of it until after the shot? Or is the method it must follow to make the documentary as 'real' as possible?
Thursday, October 9, 2008
Tuesday, September 30, 2008
1) Prairie home companion represents the last vestiges of the radio drama - an entirely aural mass media story. When television first overtook radio, there were those that said it was less 'creative' because the viewer didn't have to imagine anything and could sit passively. Do you agree with this? Is audio inherently more involved than audio+video?
Television undoubtedly destroyed radio drama, and its influence on the world was unprecedented. Not because it allowed laziness of imagination, but because it transformed ability of foreign images to reach the mind. Although the screen is a passive viewing device, the mind is able to take such images and remember them, far better than the memory of imagined places (similar to how you forget dreams). I do agree that it makes you more passive in your viewing, but overall, I feel the tv can actually inspire more imagination as it provides images we would never be able to produce independently in our minds eye. Still, the radio requires more involvement, but i do not feel it makes us less creative.
Television undoubtedly destroyed radio drama, and its influence on the world was unprecedented. Not because it allowed laziness of imagination, but because it transformed ability of foreign images to reach the mind. Although the screen is a passive viewing device, the mind is able to take such images and remember them, far better than the memory of imagined places (similar to how you forget dreams). I do agree that it makes you more passive in your viewing, but overall, I feel the tv can actually inspire more imagination as it provides images we would never be able to produce independently in our minds eye. Still, the radio requires more involvement, but i do not feel it makes us less creative.
Monday, September 29, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)








